My year-long project to read many of the books listed in the American Library Association's Read These Banned Books continues. The ALA reports 2022-23 have been "banner" (pun intended) years in the movement to restrict all sorts of books. it is rather obvious that book banning and restrictions are not a passing fad but a tidal wave with little standing in its way.
A month or so ago, a single parent managed to get the Bible removed from elementary and middle school libraries in suburban Salt Lake for being vulgar, pornographic, and dealing with incest. Often it takes just one parent to present their case before a school or library board to have books they find offensive removed.
What follows are the books I have read since the update in April, along with my reaction to the reasons each made the list.
Habibi by Craig Thompson
A black and white graphic novel about a young female slave trying to escape a miserable life. There are parallels shown between Christianity and Islam beliefs, how we are part of the natural world and escaping the fate one seems destined to live.
My Thoughts: I found this book offensive, full of gratuitous nudity and sex scenes, the rape of a 12-year-old girl, and slave auctions depicted with frontal reality. This is the first book on the ALA list that I completely agree is unsuitable for anyone under 18. Frankly, I had a difficult time finishing it.
And Tango Makes Three by Richardson and Parnell
This book couldn't be more different from Habibi. It is a children's book that takes maybe 20 minutes to read and enjoy the pictures. A story of inclusion rather than exclusion, this is the true-life story of a pair of male penguins at the Central Park Zoo in New York. Their desire to be like the other penguins and have a family was finally realized when a zoo keeper gave them an abandoned egg to hatch and care for.
And Tango Makes Three is about adoption, love, family, and fulfilling a dream regardless of what is "normal." It is not about homosexuality or alternate lifestyles.
My Thoughts: objections to this children's book are so wrong on so many levels. Children will receive all the right messages from this charming book. Trying to ban it because it "promotes the homosexual agenda" and is "anti-family" instead of the message of love and saving a life is simply idiotic.
The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas
A powerful look into a life I had a hard time relating to but need to. We are all strongly molded by where and how we are raised. It took me a while to get used to the slang, speaking patterns, and expressions. They were neither good nor bad, just different.
Starr Carter lives in two very different worlds: one filled with drugs, gangs, ghetto slang, and learning how not to be shot by the police or criminals. In the other world, she goes to a mostly white, upper-class prep school. To fit in, she must avoid slang, keep her moods and behavior in check, and deny the world she goes home to every day.
The story revolves around a police shooting of a friend of hers and her internal debate on whether to report what she saw. To complicate matters, her uncle is a policeman who pressures her to not trigger community unrest over the actions of one bad cop. Starr wrestles with her decision in a way that is powerful and reflects the fact that much of life is not cut and dried. Sometimes balance is required.
My Thoughts: The message and presentation are powerful and could provoke an important discussion with a teenager who is struggling in this world. I don't think this book is appropriate for younger children but would seem an important read for those 16+.
Something Happened in Our Town by Marianne Celano, et al
A 40-page book targeted toward younger children It is the simple story of two families, one white and one black, discussing the shooting of a black man by a white policeman. This book includes important discussion points, questions about the verbiage that is used, the unique aspects of living in this society for African Americans, and the encouragement of an open discussion among family members.
My Thoughts: I believe accusations of this book being ant-police are unfounded. It is a fact that blacks are shot by the police way out of proportion to their actual percentage of the population. But, Something Happened encourages an examination of why this is occurring and a closer look at the factors involved.
This is the perfect book to stimulate a family discussion about racism, economic opportunities, and authority. In an experiment loaded with potential to teach and explore, I had a thought: after reading this book, turn the plot around with a white man being shot by a black policeman. How would the situation change? What might be the various outcomes? Why do black and white change the narrative so much?
All American Boys by Jason Reynolds
This is very much a story from today's headlines. It involves the police targeting blacks after simple traffic stops. The story builds around mistaken identities or racial hatred that flares into violence.
Virtually no one in this story sees themselves as racist, but in any situation, prejudice or making assumptions based on someone's looks reveals a racial interpretation. The white boy who witnesses his black friend's beating is faced with his own moral struggle in deciding how to respond. Matters are complicated because the policeman involved has acted as the white boy's big brother.
There is the reality that law enforcement personnel have a very difficult job that often demands split-second decision-making. But, when those actions are based on preconceived notions, the real damage can be done to people and the community.
My Thoughts: Like several of the books I read this time, the problems of stereotyping by (and of) police officers and the damage that this causes is the central theme of All American Boys. Importantly, there is the ethical dilemma that the witness must face in deciding how to react.
I can see no reason why this book should be on anyone's banned book list. It deals with important issues that don't always have clear-cut answers but always have consequences.
Beyond Magenta by Susan Kuklin
A profile of six transgender teens, both male and female, including photographs and the young people's own words that make this headline issue real and personal, with faces and feelings on raw display.
These teens struggle with being authentic to who they believe themselves to be. There is also confusion, living as an outcast, and feeling like a nobody during their transformation.
The transgender label is brought to life, with a strong sense of the motivations and struggles these people must go through.
My Thoughts: Complaints about the sexuality in the text are valid. Parts of this book are too frank for those under 13 or 14. But, for teens going through the transgender struggle, or knowing someone who is, this book would be a tremendous resource to help them feel less alone and "odd."
Nasreen's Secret School by Jeanette Winter\
This is the true story of a young Afghan girl living through a miserable time of oppression under Taliban rule. As a female, her life and worth as a human are counted as almost useless by the men in charge.
This is a picture book with minimal words per page, presented for children in an easy-to-understand way. It would be a 30-minute read for most. There is no sex, no description of violence, no rage. There is nothing but a traumatized young girl learning to open up and trust herself.
My Thoughts: For the life of me, I cannot understand any objections to this book. I find it completely appropriate for children 8+.
Next on the pile is Perks of Being a Wallflower. My reactions to it and others lie a few months in the future.
As always, your reactions and thoughts are welcome.